The remaining free agent second basemen ... not enticing

Josh Harrison

One day, the Major League Baseball lockout will end, and when it does, the White Sox will still need a second baseman.

That's assuming you don't think all-purpose player Leury Garcia is the everyday answer at the position. (Hint: He's not.)

So, here is the list of remaining free agent second basemen. Trigger warning: There are some relics from the White Sox rebuilding days on this list:

• Brad Miller
• Donovan Solano
• Niko Goodrum
• Joe Panik
• Brock Holt
• Asdrubal Cabrera
• Hanser Alberto
• Jed Lowrie
• Charlie Culberson
• Josh Harrison
• Chris Owings
• Ronald Torreyes
• Mike Freeman
• Jose Rondon
• Phil Gosselin
• Breyvic Valera
• Kean Wong
• Ryan Goins
• Tyler Ladendorf

See anyone you like there? Me neither, and the thought of Rondon or Goins coming back to the Sox sends chills down my spine.

At least one writer, The Athletic's Andy McCullough, thinks Harrison would be a good pickup for the Sox. He said as much in his "One New Year's resolution for every team" column.

Yikes! This is what it has come to? In the middle of an alleged championship window, the Sox should gamble on 34-year-old Josh Harrison and his career .719 OPS? I'll pass.

McCullough notes that Harrison has been an above-average offensive player the past two years. Not wrong. Harrison posted a 108 OPS+ in 2020, and a 106 OPS+ in 2021.

However, Harrison has struggled with both the American League teams he has played with in the past (Oakland and Detroit). Check out his AL/NL career splits:

National League: .279/.323/.411 in 965 games

American League: .220/.263/.307 in 84 games

Granted, the sample size is much smaller in the American League. And Harrison's prime years were spent in the National League, where he was a two-time All-Star with the Pittsburgh Pirates.

However, Harrison last played at an All-Star level in 2017, and the way he finished the 2021 season in Oakland was not impressive. He batted .254/.296/.341 with two homers, 22 RBIs and 10 doubles in 199 plate appearances after coming over midseason from the Washington Nationals. 

With Oakland, Harrison's OPS+ was 79, or 21% below league average. Harrison will turn 35 next July 8, and I tend to believe his struggles down the stretch in 2021 are the start of a decline at his age.

Of course, that means he's likely available on a one-year deal. ... That's right in the wheelhouse for Sox owner Jerry Reinsdorf and GM Rick Hahn!

The Sox love giving one-year deals to declining veterans, and if they do sign Harrison, count me among the unimpressed.

The standard here should be "Better than Leury Garcia." I'm not convinced Harrison will be better than Garcia in 2022.